Blog

Behavioural and human causes in TSF failures not widely researched according to ERM

Tailings Storage Facility Monitoring Governance - Rehabilitation & Closure - Decipher Cloud Platform - Global Tailings Portal - Global Tailings Standard (GTS) - Brumadinho Tailings Disaster
Mining & Resources / Tailings Storage Facilities

Behavioural and human causes in TSF failures not widely researched according to ERM

Highlights

  • Sustainability consulting firm ERM says the mining industry needs to do more to prevent tailings storage facility disasters and notes that a further 19 incidents is possible over the next decade
  • ERM stated that while the technical and engineering causes of tailings dam disasters have been widely covered and researched, the organisational and human cases has not been well researched
  • Find out the different types of TSFs
  • See what score you get for your TSF monitoring program here
  • Download this FREE guide to find out about the available solutions to help implement the Global Standard on Tailings Management

 

Sustainability consulting firm ERM says the mining industry needs to do more to prevent tailings dam disasters and notes that a further possible 19 incidents with tailings facilities could occur over the next decade.

In a report released last month, ERM reviewed the dam failure incident reports of 11 major dam failures over the last 12 years and concluded that “basic organizational and human factors, such as budgeting, operational leadership, safety and risk culture, and competence, played a significant role in each.”

Citing statistics from the World Mine Tailings Failures study released in 2019, ERM noted that historically there have been between two and five major failures and 35 minor failures annually.

“Minimizing the risk of tailings dam failures is one of the greatest challenges facing the sector,” ERM stated in its report. “Despite the billions of dollars being invested and the recent launch of a global industry standard on tailings management, there is a concern that the industry is destined to do ‘too little too late’ to prevent further catastrophic incidents.”

While the technical and engineering causes of tailings dam disasters have been covered extensively and include three major factors – slope instability, overtopping and foundation stability – ERM stated, “unfortunately the organizational and human or ‘adaptive’ causes have not been so well researched and yet these have been just as significant in contributing to catastrophic failures.”

“An over-reliance on engineering standards and considerations has led to a focus on the low likelihood of tailings dam failures – yet they continue to occur,” ERM noted.

A worker surveys the damage at the Brumadinho dam disaster in Brazil. Photo by Diego Baravelli/Wikimedia Commons.

One problem is that decision-makers “often rely on layers of controls that are reviewed by peers, subject matter experts and independent boards,” ERM found, but “do not dig deeply enough into how the controls are being implemented and how well they are understood by the workers managing the dam.”

“Indeed in almost all cases when a third party review is conducted of a tailings storage facility (TSF) considering the management of controls (e.g. training, deviation reporting, corrective action tracking, communication, and governance processes), significant breakdowns emerge quite readily. Any control strategy cannot be devoid of the human factor.”

ERM noted that based on disclosed information on about 600 TSFs around the world, there are more than 1.3 million people living downstream and within 20 km of the waste storage dams. Of those, 57% live downstream of TSFs built using “upstream” construction methods. According to ERM, the upstream model “is considered to be the lowest initial cost for a raised tailings embankment due to the minimal amount of initial fill material required,” noting that about half of these upstream models are operational and another 25% are described as ‘inactive’ but haven’t been closed down or rehabilitated.

“Our analysis has considered the location and topography of these TSFs as well as the plausible flow trajectories,” ERM said. “Using satellite imagery, we have estimated that more than 70,000 sq. km of land, (an area the size of Scotland) is at risk of impact from these tailings facilities should they fail.”

ERM also found that those people of greatest risk are living downstream of TSFs associated with copper mining operations.

In an interview, Louise Pearce, ERM’s global managing mining and metals lead, said the report followed up data published by The Investor Mining & Tailings Safety Initiative, which is led by the Church of England Pension Board and Sweden’s AP Funds Council of Ethics. In April 2019, the Initiative requested dam-by-dam disclosure information from mining companies after 270 people were killed in the Vale tailings dam disaster at Brumadinho in Brazil.

The request was issued to over 600 companies and was backed by 100 investors with nearly US$13 trillion in assets under management. Most major mining companies, Pearce said, have committed to implementing the standard and ERM sees this as a great step.

“Our paper highlights the need to pay more attention to the human factors associated with managing dams safely and the importance of considering the downstream consequences, with much greater rigor,” Pearce said. “When implementing the global standards, mining companies need to place an early emphasis on the community and the human aspects equally with engineering design consideration.”

“Are you talking to the communities? Do they really know how much time they have to react if something goes wrong?”

Originally published by Northern Miner.

Watch the vodcast – Working towards zero harm: tailings monitoring & governance in 2021

 


Effectively monitor your tailings storage facility with Decipher

Tailings Storage Facilities - TSF - Mining - Decipher - DecipherGreen - Tailings management - tailings dam monitoring - tailings storage facility software - environmental obligations software

Decipher’s Tailings solution is designed to provide you with key data and insights, enabling you to effectively monitor your TSF and your environmental obligations and compliance. Our solution can be securely accessed by industry, regulators, designers and operators involved in the management of TSFs.

Decipher offers a comprehensive and functionally rich solution which combines regulatory (Compliance Management Software), mining waste management, stakeholder engagement, environmental monitoring, and environmental management system (EMS) tools to assist with tailings management:

  • View real-time data and receive exceedance alerts
  • Monitor land movement with remote sensing and InSAR datasets
  • Visualise real-time LiDAR data with insights into dam movement
  • Securely store and access all of your tailings data in the one place
  • Upload and reference key documentation
  • Visualise facilities across multiple sites in a single screen on a geospatial map
  • Monitor your facilities with InSAR, LiDAR, DEM and more
  • Capture a wide range of monitoring data and indicators su
    ch as surface and groundwater, decant pond water levels and quality, and embankment conditions
  • Capture and track obligations and conditions around your licence to operate to manage your key risks and actions
  • Action and task delegation for data collection with reminders
  • Maintain and track environmental monitoring compliance limits and exceedances
  • Manage and engage with all of your stakeholders with one central repository
  • Convert your engagements into actionable outcomes
  • Forecast, plan and track your sites activities using IBM’s Weather data
  • Create corporate report templates and meet requests for data provision from industry groups such as ICMM, Global Tailings Portal, PRI and UNEP
  • Integration capability with third party systems or public portals such as the Global Tailings Portal

Organise a free trial to see what’s possible today.  

Request a demo

 


Want to find out more about tailings storage monitoring?

Don’t miss another update!

K2fly acquires Decipher to expand Enterprise Resource Governance and Technical Assurance Suite
This is default text for notification bar